Akṣapāda Gautama
The traditional author of the Nyaya-sutra, the founding text of the Indian school of logic and epistemology.
Life
Nothing reliable is known about the life of Akṣapāda Gautama. Tradition names him as the author of the Nyaya-sutra, a collection of about five hundred aphorisms setting out a method for inquiry and debate. He is a different person from Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha.
Scholars think the text was compiled in stages and reached roughly its present form around the second century CE. It is read through a chain of commentaries, beginning with that of Vatsyayana in about the fifth century.
Core ideas
- There are four means of valid knowledge: perception, inference, comparison (analogy) and reliable testimony.
- A formal inference has five steps: thesis, reason, example, application and conclusion.
- A catalogue of fallacies and of unfair moves in debate.
- The self is an enduring substance, distinct from the body, the senses and the mind.
- Liberation is achieved through correct knowledge, which removes the errors that cause suffering.
In more depth
The text. The Nyaya-sutra is a collection of terse aphorisms that founded the Nyaya school. It was assembled over time and is read with later commentaries, beginning with Vatsyayana's. Its opening lists sixteen topics, knowledge of which leads to the highest good, liberation. Most concern the conduct of inquiry and debate.
Means of knowledge. Nyaya recognises four sources of valid cognition. Perception arises from contact of a sense with its object. Inference is knowledge that follows on perception, as of fire from smoke. Comparison is knowing a thing through its likeness to something familiar. Testimony is the instruction of a trustworthy person. The Buddhists accepted only the first two, and the dispute over the others runs through Indian philosophy.
The inference pattern. A formal argument has five members. The hill has fire. Because it has smoke. Whatever has smoke has fire, as in a kitchen. This hill has smoke. Therefore it has fire. The example is essential: the general connection must be shown in an agreed case. Later Nyaya refined the account of the invariable relation between sign and thing signified.
Doubt and debate. Inquiry begins from doubt and proceeds by examining both sides. The sutras distinguish honest discussion aimed at truth from disputation aimed at victory and from mere cavil, and catalogue fallacious reasons, quibbles and the points at which a debater is defeated.
Realism. The world exists independently of our knowing it. Substances are distinct from their qualities, and wholes from their parts. Cognition reveals objects and is not itself the object.
The self. Desire, aversion, effort, pleasure, pain and knowledge are the marks of the self. Recognition, in which I identify what I see now with what I saw before, requires a single enduring subject of experience. This was aimed at the Buddhist denial of self. Suffering ends when false knowledge is removed. Later members of the school developed proofs of God.
The sixteen topics. The Nyaya-sutra opens by saying that the highest good comes from knowledge of sixteen things: the means of knowledge, the objects of knowledge, doubt, purpose, example, established tenet, the members of an argument, hypothetical reasoning, ascertainment, honest discussion, disputation, wrangling, fallacious reasons, quibbling, false rejoinders and grounds for defeat. The list is a curriculum for debate. Logic in India developed out of the rules of public argument.
Three kinds of debate. Discussion is argument between those who seek the truth, each side using proper means of proof. Disputation aims at victory and allows tricks. Wrangling is criticism of the other side with no thesis of one's own. The sutra lists the tricks, such as taking a word in a sense the speaker did not intend, and twenty-two situations in which a debater is judged to have lost, for example by abandoning his thesis or repeating himself.
Perception defined. Perception is knowledge that arises from contact of a sense organ with its object, that is not dependent on words, that does not err, and that is definite. Each qualification answers an objection. “Does not err” excludes a mirage; “definite” excludes seeing something in the distance and wondering whether it is smoke or dust. Later Nyaya distinguished a first, non-conceptual stage of perception from a second stage in which the object is grasped as of a kind.
The chain to liberation. The second sutra gives a causal series: pain depends on birth, birth on activity, activity on faults such as attachment and aversion, and faults on false knowledge. When false knowledge is removed by true knowledge, each later link is removed in turn, and liberation follows, which the school describes as the absolute absence of pain. Logic is therefore presented as serving the same end as the other Indian systems.
The tradition. The sutras were explained by Vatsyayana around the fifth century, and defended against Buddhist criticism by Uddyotakara and others. Udayana, in the eleventh century, wrote a celebrated proof of God as the maker of the world. From the fourteenth century the New Nyaya of Gangesha developed a highly technical language for analysing cognition, which became the common idiom of Indian philosophy.
Works
- Nyaya-sutra, compiled c. 200 BCE–200 CE
Where scholars disagree
Whether the Nyaya-sutra is the work of one author is doubtful, and estimates of its date vary by several centuries.
A common misreading
He is frequently confused with the Buddha because both are called Gautama, a common clan name. The two belong to different centuries and opposed traditions.
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Akṣapāda Gautama in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.