Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Protagoras

c. 490 BCE – c. 420 BCE · Abdera, Thrace; Athens · Greek and Roman

The most famous of the Sophists, known for the claim that “man is the measure of all things”.

Life

Protagoras came from Abdera and spent some forty years as a travelling teacher, visiting Athens several times and becoming an associate of the statesman Pericles. He was among the first to call himself a sophist and to charge fees for teaching the skills of public life.

His books are lost apart from a few sentences. Our picture of him depends largely on Plato, a critic, who portrays him with some respect in the Protagoras and examines his relativism in the Theaetetus.

Core ideas

In more depth

Man the measure. The opening of Protagoras' book Truth said that man is the measure of all things: of the things that are, that they are, and of the things that are not, that they are not. Plato, in the Theaetetus, reads this as the claim that things are for each person as they appear to that person. If the wind feels cold to me and warm to you, it is cold for me and warm for you, and there is no further fact about how the wind is in itself.

The objection from self-refutation. Plato's Socrates replies that most people believe the measure doctrine is false. If every belief is true for the one who holds it, then it is true for them that the doctrine is false, and Protagoras must grant this. Whether the argument succeeds depends on whether “true for” can be dropped at the last step, and that is still discussed.

Teaching without absolute truth. If no belief is truer than another, what does a teacher offer? The reply Plato constructs for Protagoras is that some beliefs are better than others in their effects, as a doctor changes how food seems to a sick man. The sophist does the same for cities. Protagoras also claimed to make the weaker argument the stronger and held that there are two opposed arguments on every question.

Gods and virtue. His book on the gods began by saying he could not know whether they exist, because the subject is obscure and human life is short. In Plato's Protagoras he argues, through a myth, that a sense of justice and respect is shared by all citizens and can be taught, which is a defence of democratic practice.

The sophist's profession. Protagoras was the first to call himself a sophist and to charge a fee. What he offered, by Plato's report, was good judgement in one's own affairs and in the affairs of the city: how to speak and act most effectively. In democratic Athens, where policy and lawsuits were decided by persuading large bodies of citizens, this was a valuable skill, and the claim that it could be taught was itself a political claim, since it denied that excellence belongs by birth to the well-born.

The Great Speech. In Plato's Protagoras he tells a myth. Epimetheus handed out powers to the animals and left humans with none; Prometheus stole fire and the crafts for them; but they still could not live together until Zeus sent justice and a sense of shame, to be shared by all and not, like medicine, given to a few. That is why Athenians listen to anyone on political questions. And everyone teaches virtue, as everyone teaches children their native language, so it is no objection that there are no recognised experts.

Opposed arguments. A surviving anonymous text, the Double Arguments, shows the practice: on each topic it argues that the good and the bad are the same and then that they are different. The training was useful for the courts, and it has a philosophical side. If on every matter two cases can be made, then no matter is settled by argument alone, and one needs some other account of why one side should prevail. Protagoras's answer was usefulness.

What kind of relativism. Scholars distinguish a relativism about perception (the wind is cold for the one who feels it cold), which is hard to dispute, from a relativism about all judgements, including judgements about what is just or true. Plato attributes the second to him and attacks it. The surviving evidence is too thin to be sure how far Protagoras went, and some hold that Plato extended the doctrine in order to refute it.

In their words

Of all things the measure is man: of the things that are, that they are, and of the things that are not, that they are not.

Opening of Truth, as quoted in Plato, Theaetetus 152a

Works

Where scholars disagree

It is debated whether “man” in the measure doctrine means each individual, as Plato reads it, or humankind collectively.

A common misreading

“Sophist” was not originally an insult. It meant an expert or teacher; the sense of a dishonest reasoner comes largely from the hostile portraits by Plato and Aristotle.

Influenced by

Heraclitus

Influenced

Socrates, Plato

Schools and eras

Classical Greek

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Protagoras in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.