Paulin Hountondji
Beninese philosopher who attacked the idea of a collective, unwritten African philosophy as ethnophilosophy.
Life
Hountondji was born in Abidjan to a family from Dahomey, now Benin, and studied in Paris at the École Normale Supérieure under Althusser and Jacques Derrida, writing on Edmund Husserl. He taught in Zaire and from 1972 at the national university in Cotonou. After the end of military rule in Benin he served as minister of education and of culture in the early 1990s.
Core ideas
- Ethnophilosophy mistakes a people's collective world-view for philosophy.
- Philosophy is a body of written texts by individuals, engaged in argument with one another.
- African philosophy is philosophy produced by Africans, whatever its subject.
- The myth of African unanimity serves both colonial and authoritarian interests.
- African research is extraverted: directed to audiences and questions set elsewhere.
In more depth
The target. In 1945 the Belgian missionary Placide Tempels published Bantu Philosophy, which claimed that Bantu peoples share an implicit ontology of vital force. African writers such as Alexis Kagame and John Mbiti followed with similar reconstructions from language, proverbs and custom. Hountondji named this genre ethnophilosophy and called it a myth. It assumes that all members of a society think alike; it locates philosophy in a silent collective mind where no one can argue with it; and it was written, first of all, for a European public curious about the African soul. What is presented as African philosophy is the philosophy of the ethnographer.
What philosophy is. Hountondji insists on a strict sense. Philosophy is not a system of beliefs that people hold. It is a history: a set of texts in which individuals put forward claims, criticise one another and are answered. It needs writing, because criticism needs a stable text. African philosophy therefore exists as the literature produced by Africans and described by them as philosophical, including his own criticism of ethnophilosophy. He adds a political point. Regimes that invoke an authentic African way of thinking use it to silence dissent as un-African.
Critics and later work. Opponents charged him with elitism and with adopting a European definition that excludes oral wisdom; Kwasi Wiredu and Odera Oruka looked for individual critical thinkers within traditional societies. Hountondji later softened his position and turned to what he called endogenous knowledge: the study and testing of traditional knowledge of medicine, agriculture and craft. He also analysed the dependency of African science, which exports data and imports theory, as raw materials were exported and manufactures imported.
Works
- African Philosophy: Myth and Reality, 1976; English 1983
- The Struggle for Meaning, 1997; English 2002
Influenced by
Edmund Husserl, Jacques Derrida, Karl Marx
Influenced
Kwasi Wiredu, Kwame Anthony Appiah
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Paulin Hountondji in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.