Zhuangzi
Daoist thinker whose book uses parable, humour and paradox to question fixed distinctions and conventional values.
Life
According to Sima Qian, Zhuang Zhou came from Meng in the state of Song, held a minor post there, and refused an offer of high office from the king of Chu, saying he would sooner drag his tail in the mud like a living turtle. Almost nothing else is known of him.
The book called Zhuangzi has thirty-three chapters. Only the first seven, the “Inner Chapters”, are generally attributed to him, and the rest are the work of later writers in several related traditions.
Core ideas
- Judgements of right and wrong, beautiful and ugly, depend on perspective; no standpoint is privileged.
- The butterfly dream: on waking, he does not know whether he is Zhuang Zhou who dreamed he was a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming it is Zhuang Zhou.
- Skilled, spontaneous activity, like that of Cook Ding carving an ox, shows how to move with the Dao.
- The “useless” tree lives out its years; usefulness invites harm.
- Life and death are phases of one process of transformation, to be accepted with equanimity.
In more depth
The book. The Zhuangzi is a collection, of which the first seven chapters are usually ascribed to Zhuang Zhou himself. It argues through stories, jokes, dialogues with invented characters and sudden reversals, so that a reader is seldom sure which voice to trust. That uncertainty is part of what it teaches.
Perspectives. Humans think a certain woman beautiful, but fish dive at the sight of her and birds fly off. Who knows the right standard? Every judgement of this and that, right and wrong, is made from a position. The Confucians and Mohists each affirm what the other denies. Zhuangzi recommends illuminating the matter from the standpoint of the hinge of the Way, from which this and that are not opposed.
The butterfly. He dreamed he was a butterfly, content and unaware of being Zhuang Zhou. On waking he did not know whether he was Zhuang Zhou who had dreamed of being a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming he was Zhuang Zhou. The story is usually read with his remarks on the transformation of things, and not as a simple sceptical argument.
Skill. Cook Ding carves an ox without ever dulling his blade, because he follows the natural structure, moving through the gaps. He says that what he cares about is the Way, which goes beyond skill. This and similar tales of wheelwrights and swimmers present a kind of knowing that is responsive, unforced and beyond words.
Uselessness and death. A crooked tree is spared by the carpenter and lives out its years. Usefulness to others is a danger. When his wife died Zhuangzi was found drumming on a pot and singing: she had changed as the seasons change, and to weep would show he did not understand fate. Life and death are phases of one process.
Free wandering. The ideal is to wander at ease, depending on nothing, with a mind fasted of fixed judgements.
Readings. Scholars disagree on whether he is a sceptic, a relativist or a mystic. Xunzi complained that he was blinded by Heaven and did not know man.
The fish and the bird. The book opens with a fish thousands of miles long that changes into a bird whose wings are like clouds across the sky, and which rises ninety thousand miles to fly south. A cicada and a little dove laugh at it: we fly up to the elm and sometimes do not reach it; what is the use of going so far? Small understanding cannot reach great understanding. But the bird depends on the wind as much as the dove on the branch; what would it be to depend on nothing?
Three in the morning. A keeper of monkeys told them they would have three nuts in the morning and four at night. They were furious. Very well, he said, four in the morning and three at night, and they were delighted. Nothing had changed in fact, yet joy and anger were set in motion. Those who wear out their minds insisting that things are one way, without seeing that it is all the same, are like the monkeys. The sage harmonises right and wrong and rests in what the text calls walking two roads.
The happiness of fish. Zhuangzi and Hui Shi stroll on a bridge over the Hao. Zhuangzi remarks on how the minnows dart about: that is the happiness of fish. Hui Shi: you are not a fish; how do you know? Zhuangzi: you are not I; how do you know I do not know? Hui Shi: I am not you and do not know you; you are not a fish, so you do not know them. Zhuangzi: go back to your question. You asked how I know, so you already knew that I knew. I know it from here above the Hao.
The death of his wife. When Zhuangzi's wife died, Hui Shi found him drumming on a tub and singing. At first, he explained, I grieved like anyone. Then I looked back to the time before she had life, before she had form, before she had breath. In the midst of the jumble there was a change and she had breath, form, life; now there is another change and she is dead, like the progression of the four seasons. To follow her sobbing would show that I do not understand what is ordained.
The fasting of the mind. Confucius, here made a spokesman for the author, advises a disciple to fast the mind: do not listen with the ears but with the mind; do not listen with the mind but with the vital breath, which is empty and waits on things. Elsewhere a disciple reports that he sits and forgets everything. The text also tells of Hundun, Chaos, who died when his friends kindly bored seven openings in him.
Works
- Zhuangzi, Inner Chapters c. late 4th century BCE; whole text compiled by c. 2nd century BCE
Where scholars disagree
Whether Zhuangzi is best read as a sceptic, a relativist, a mystic or something else is one of the liveliest debates in the study of Chinese philosophy.
A common misreading
Zhuangzi is often treated as a disciple of Laozi who expounded the Daodejing. The Inner Chapters do not quote it, and the grouping of the two as a single “Daoist school” was made by Han dynasty historians.
Influenced by
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Zhuangzi in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.