Zera Yacob
Ethiopian thinker credited with the Hatata, a treatise that tests religious teaching and custom against the judgement of reason.
Life
According to the autobiographical opening of the Hatata, Zera Yacob was born near Aksum in 1599 to a poor farming family and educated in the traditional church schools. When the emperor Susenyos adopted Roman Catholicism and persecuted opponents, he was denounced, fled, and lived for two years in a cave, where he worked out his philosophy in solitude.
After the emperor's death he settled in Enfraz as a scribe and teacher. He wrote the treatise in 1667 at the request of his pupil Walda Heywat, who later added a treatise of his own.
Core ideas
- Every doctrine and custom must be examined by reason, the light that God has given to all people.
- The existence of a good creator can be inferred from the existence and order of created things.
- What agrees with reason and with the nature of creation is true; rules that contradict them, such as those condemning marriage, are human inventions.
- The disagreements among the religions show that each mixes truth with error.
- Men and women are equal in marriage, and slavery is wrong.
In more depth
A warning about the source. The Hatata presents itself as the autobiography and inquiry of an Ethiopian thinker of the seventeenth century. It is known from manuscripts sent to Europe in the nineteenth century, and since 1920 some scholars have argued that it was composed by an Italian missionary. Others defend its authenticity on linguistic and historical grounds. The question is not settled, and what follows describes the content of the text.
The starting point. The narrator, a teacher caught between Ethiopian Orthodox and Catholic factions, flees persecution and lives in a cave. There he reflects on the fact that each faith declares itself true and the others false. All cannot be right, and each person simply follows what they were taught. He resolves to examine everything by the light of reason that God has given to all.
God and reason. He argues that he did not create himself and that the chain of parents cannot go back for ever, so there is an uncreated creator, who is intelligent because he has made intelligent beings. Since God is good and has given everyone reason, whatever agrees with reason is from God, and whatever conflicts with it is of human invention.
The test applied. On this basis he judges particular teachings. The order of nature shows that marriage is good, so monastic celibacy is not superior. Fasting rules that harm the body, the permission of slavery and the claim that any people is uniquely chosen all fail the test. The golden rule and the duty to work pass it.
A companion text. A second treatise, attributed to his pupil Walda Heywat, restates the doctrine with more practical advice.
The story the text tells. The narrator says he was born near Aksum in 1599 to a poor farming family, was educated in the church schools in chant, poetry and scriptural interpretation, and became a teacher. When King Susenyos adopted Catholicism under Jesuit influence, he was denounced by a rival and fled with some gold and his Psalter. He lived two years in a cave, praying and thinking, and later settled in a town as tutor to a rich man's sons, one of whom, Walda Heywat, asked him to write.
The argument from disagreement. Each faith, he observes, says “my faith is true and the others false”, and each takes its own on the word of its fathers. People do not examine because inquiry is laborious. But if the believers of every creed are equally confident and equally unable to give proof, their confidence proves nothing. God has given reason so that each person can judge. He asks why God allows people to be misled, and answers that truth is given to those who seek it sincerely.
What reason rejects. The narrator applies his test to particular teachings. Monastic celibacy conflicts with the creator's evident purpose in making man and woman. Fasting rules treat as unclean what was made for nourishment. Polygamy fails because men and women are born in equal numbers. Slavery is wrong because all are equal before the creator. Holy war is a human invention. Marriage is to be a partnership, and he says he treated his own wife as an equal and not as a servant.
The state of the question. The Italian Capuchin Giusto da Urbino, who sent the manuscripts to Paris in the 1850s, was accused in 1920 by the scholar Carlo Conti Rossini of having composed them. Claude Sumner's studies in the 1970s argued for Ethiopian authorship on grounds of language and style, and many scholars followed him. The question has since been reopened on both sides. Readers should treat the attribution as probable or disputed, not as settled.
Works
- Hatata (Inquiry), 1667
Where scholars disagree
The authenticity of the Hatata is contested. In 1920 the scholar Carlo Conti Rossini argued that it was written in the nineteenth century by Giusto da Urbino, the Italian missionary who sent the manuscripts to Europe. Claude Sumner and others have defended Ethiopian authorship on linguistic and historical grounds, and the question remains open. The dates given here are those stated in the text.
A common misreading
He is a different person from the fifteenth-century Ethiopian emperor of the same name.
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Zera Yacob in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.