Diogenes of Sinope
The archetypal Cynic, who lived in deliberate poverty and mocked convention in order to show that virtue needs nothing external.
Life
Diogenes came from Sinope on the Black Sea and arrived in Athens as an exile, reportedly after he or his father was involved in defacing the city's coinage. He lived as a beggar, sheltering in a large storage jar, and made his life a public demonstration of his philosophy.
Nothing he wrote survives. He is known through anecdotes collected centuries later, which were already in antiquity told for their wit and cannot be verified. The most famous has him tell Alexander the Great, who offered him any favour, to stand out of his sunlight.
Core ideas
- Happiness lies in living according to nature, which requires very little.
- Social conventions about shame, status and property have no rational authority.
- Self-sufficiency and freedom of speech are the marks of the wise person.
- Asked where he came from, he is said to have called himself a “citizen of the world” (kosmopolitēs).
In more depth
A philosophy that was lived. Diogenes left no surviving writings and built no theory. His philosophy consisted in a way of living, known through anecdotes that are often unreliable in detail but consistent in what they show. He owned almost nothing, slept in a storage jar, and performed in public the bodily acts that custom keeps private.
Nature against convention. The principle behind the behaviour is that happiness requires only virtue, that virtue is living according to nature, and that most of what cities demand is mere convention. Wealth, reputation, status and shame at natural functions are conventional and enslave those who pursue or fear them. The slogan attributed to him, to deface the currency, plays on the word for both coinage and custom.
Training and freedom. Cynic self-sufficiency is achieved by askesis, deliberate hardening against cold, hunger and humiliation, so that nothing fortune removes can matter. With it goes parrhesia, complete freedom of speech, including toward the powerful. The story of his telling Alexander to stand out of his sunlight expresses it, whatever its truth.
Citizen of the world. Asked where he came from, he is said to have answered that he was a kosmopolites, a citizen of the cosmos. In context this was a refusal of loyalty to any one city more than a positive doctrine. The Stoics, whose founder studied with a Cynic, turned it into one, and kept the Cynic claim that virtue is sufficient for happiness while giving up the scandal.
The anecdote as argument. Each story about Diogenes carries a claim. He carries a lit lamp through the marketplace in daylight and says he is looking for a human being: the people around him do not count as examples. He sees a child drink from cupped hands and throws away his cup, since even that was more than nature needs. He asks a statue for alms, to practise being refused. Told that Plato has defined man as a featherless biped, he plucks a chicken and brings it to the Academy.
Shamelessness as method. Diogenes ate, slept and satisfied bodily needs in public. The reasoning is simple: if an act is not wrong, it is not wrong in the marketplace. Shame attaches by convention, and conventions are just what he means to test. The nickname “dog”, from which the word Cynic comes, was first an insult that he accepted: the dog lives by nature, knows friend from enemy, and is not embarrassed.
Against theory. Diogenes was a contemporary of Plato and treated his lectures as a waste of time. When a philosopher argued that motion is impossible, he is said to have stood up and walked. The Cynic position is that virtue needs strength and practice, not learning, and that most of what passes for philosophy is another way of avoiding the work of living well. The Stoics kept the practice and restored the theory.
The legacy. The line of teachers runs from Diogenes to Crates, who gave away his wealth, and from Crates to Zeno of Citium, who founded the Stoa. Cynicism itself survived for centuries as a movement of wandering preachers. Christian asceticism shows its influence, and the modern word “cynical”, meaning a disbelief in anyone's good motives, keeps only the mockery and loses the moral seriousness.
Works
- Works attributed to him, including a Republic, are lost, —
A common misreading
Ancient “Cynicism” is not modern cynicism. The Cynics were not sneering pessimists about human motives; they were ascetic moralists who believed virtue was attainable and sufficient for happiness.
Influenced by
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Diogenes of Sinope in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.