Chrysippus
Third head of the Stoic school, who systematised its doctrine and developed a logic of propositions.
Life
Chrysippus came from Soli in Cilicia, in what is now southern Turkey. He studied in Athens under Cleanthes and succeeded him as head of the Stoa around 230 BCE. He defended and reorganised Stoic doctrine against attacks from the sceptical Academy.
He was said to have written more than 700 works. None survives intact, and his views must be reconstructed from quotations by later, often hostile, writers. An ancient saying ran that without Chrysippus there would have been no Stoa.
Core ideas
- A logic of whole propositions connected by “if”, “and” and “or”, distinct from Aristotle's logic of terms.
- Everything happens by fate, an unbroken chain of causes, yet our actions are “up to us” because they flow from our own character and assent.
- Emotions are mistaken judgements of value, and can be removed by correcting the judgements.
- The cosmos is periodically consumed by fire and renewed.
In more depth
His place. Chrysippus took over a school under heavy attack from the Academy and rebuilt its doctrines in detail. An ancient saying had it that without Chrysippus there would have been no Stoa. None of his very many books survives whole; his views are reconstructed from quotations, often hostile.
Logic. His logic deals with whole propositions, where Aristotle's dealt with terms. He identified basic valid argument forms, among them: if the first, then the second; the first; so the second. Other valid arguments were to be reduced to these. He also worked on paradoxes such as the Liar. This propositional logic was neglected for centuries and recognised as a major achievement only after modern logic rediscovered the same ground.
Fate and responsibility. Everything happens by fate, an unbroken chain of causes that is also divine providence. To show that actions are still up to us, Chrysippus distinguished the cause that sets something off from the cause that determines how it responds. A push starts a cylinder rolling, but it rolls because of its own shape. An impression prompts us, but whether we assent depends on our character, so we are answerable for what we do. To the lazy argument, that if recovery is fated there is no point calling a doctor, he replied that calling the doctor may be fated together with the recovery.
The passions. Chrysippus treated the soul's commanding part as wholly rational. A passion is a judgement, an assent to the false impression that something indifferent is good or bad, with an excessive impulse that follows. Because passions are judgements they can be removed by correcting belief. Posidonius later objected that this cannot explain why emotion fades while the belief remains.
The five indemonstrables. Chrysippus identified five basic argument forms. If the first, the second; the first; so the second. If the first, the second; not the second; so not the first. Not both the first and the second; the first; so not the second. Either the first or the second; the first; so not the second. Either the first or the second; not the first; so the second. “First” and “second” stand for whole propositions. The ancient story that even a hunting dog uses the fifth, when it sniffs two paths and takes the third without sniffing, was told to illustrate it.
Sayables. The Stoics distinguished three things: the spoken sound, the object referred to, and what is said, the lekton. A foreigner hears the sound and sees the object but misses the third. The sayable is not a body, and since the Stoics held that only bodies exist, they gave sayables a lesser status: they subsist. Truth and falsity belong to complete sayables, that is, to propositions. This is close to the modern distinction between a sentence and the proposition it expresses.
Breath and blending. Chrysippus developed the physics of pneuma, a blend of fire and air that runs through all bodies and holds them together by its tension. In stones it is mere cohesion; in plants, nature; in animals, soul; in humans, reason. For pneuma to pervade a body, two bodies must be able to occupy the same place completely, so he defended a theory of total blending, on which a drop of wine extends through the whole sea.
The heap. The sorites paradox asks: one grain is not a heap; adding one grain never turns what is not a heap into a heap; so no number of grains is a heap. Chrysippus's advice was to stop answering before the cases become unclear, like a driver who reins in his horses before the cliff. Critics said this was evasion. On one modern reading he held that there is a sharp boundary that we cannot know, a position revived in recent work on vagueness.
Works
- Over 700 works reported, including Logical Investigations and On Fate; fragments only, c. 240–206 BCE
A common misreading
Stoic logic was long dismissed as a poor copy of Aristotle's. Since the twentieth century it has been recognised as an independent and sophisticated propositional logic.
Influenced by
Influenced
Schools and eras
Stoicism, Hellenistic and Roman
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Chrysippus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.